Scribie is exclusive amongst transcription services because of its ‘human-in-the-loop’ mannequin: It primarily makes use of an computerized course of, however a human edits the ultimate model of a script earlier than sending it again to you. The technique works properly, producing correct recordsdata in testing. Scribie prices a aggressive fee and has a slick, easy-to-use net interface. That mentioned, no cell apps can be found for the service. Against this, the AI-enhanced Otter has excellent cell apps and helpful instruments for stay conferences, whereas GoTranscript affords the perfect human-based transcripts we obtained in testing, making these two companies our Editors’ Selection winners.
How A lot Does Scribie Value?
Scribie has simple pricing that begins at $0.80 per audio minute. The usual turnaround time is 24 hours. You pay an additional $0.50 per minute for a strict verbatim transcription or $1.25 per minute for a faster turnaround. Scribie says it additionally affords a subscription choice upon request.
(Credit score: Scribie/PCMag)
For comparability, GoTranscript’s absolutely human-based transcription service begins at $1.20 per minute with a five-day turnaround. Transcripts with a one-day turnaround time price $1.60 per minute, and timestamps price further. TranscribeMe prices $1.25 per minute for its equal service with a turnaround time of as much as three days. Including timestamps and speaker identification, which Scribie contains in its base fee, provides to that worth. Rev‘s human-based service prices $1.99 per minute and has a turnaround time of 12 hours.
As for automated transcription companies, some provide pay-as-you-go pricing, and others use a subscription mannequin. TranscribeMe’s per-job automated service prices simply $0.07 per minute. Otter’s Professional subscription ($8.33 per person per 30 days, billed yearly) helps as much as 1,200 automated transcription minutes per 30 days. Rev’s Fundamental VoiceHub plan ($9.99 per person per 30 days, billed yearly) may be very related.
Getting Began With Scribie
You want a Scribie account to submit an order. Scribie’s net dashboard has a spacious, trendy design. It has navigation gadgets on the left, a big file add space on the prime, and a listing of your recordsdata on the backside. It even has a darkish and lightweight mode. We often encountered navigational bugs on the positioning, nevertheless it works properly total.
Scribie allows you to add a file out of your laptop, numerous online storage services, or YouTube, however you possibly can’t document stay audio like with Otter and Rev. As soon as you’re able to submit an order, merely search for your file within the checklist of uploads and click on the related Transcribe button below the Actions column. Scribie then brings you to a web page the place you possibly can specify order choices, add any feedback, and submit the job.
(Credit score: Scribie/PCMag)
The left-hand menu has an In Progress part for monitoring orders. As soon as your order is full, you will discover it within the Delivered part. From there, you possibly can open the transcript within the net editor, reserve it to your native gadget, share it, or add it to a cloud storage service of your alternative. You too can order a Re-Evaluate in the event you really feel Scribie delivered subpar outcomes.
Scribie does not provide cell apps. You’ll be able to log in to Scribie by way of your cellphone’s browser and add recordsdata, though the web site does not translate properly to a smaller display screen dimension. You usually need to scroll horizontally and vertically to entry options. For comparability, Otter, Rev, and Trint all have slick, full-featured cell apps with recording and enhancing capabilities.
Enhancing and Collaboration
Scribie’s net editor matches the design of the dashboard and contains principally customary capabilities. You get instruments for adjusting the playback quantity and pace, together with these for rapidly parsing a file. Scribie offers a complete checklist of keyboard shortcuts by way of the drop-down menu on the higher proper, however oddly none for including daring, italics, or underlining. (Ctrl + B appeared to work high-quality for making textual content daring, nonetheless). You’ll be able to add notes in a sidebar space, although you aren’t getting any of the superior AI summarization instruments of Otter, not to mention the story-building options of Trint.
(Credit score: Scribie/PCMag)
Scribie helps crew workspaces for enhancing, listening to, and sharing transcripts with colleagues. To take action, you must create a crew, invite your coworkers, and specify roles (person, supervisor, supervisor, crew admin).
How Correct Is Scribie?
As talked about, Scribie sometimes makes use of an computerized course of for the preliminary transcription, after which a human steps in to finish the job and guarantee accuracy. For conditions wherein the transcript comprises many errors (usually as a result of low audio high quality), a human transcriber takes over to provide the transcript manually. You’ll be able to learn in regards to the particulars here.
We examined Scribie with a two-minute iPhone audio recording of a passage from Marguerite Henry’s “Misty of Chincoteague” collection. We selected the 12-hour turnaround choice, which added $1.25 per minute to the order. It got here again a lot quicker than 12 hours (simply 48 minutes on this case).
Scribie’s human-verified transcript is almost flawless. Troublesome place names like Assateague, Chincoteague, and Pocomoke are all correct. The final time we examined the service, the one curious error was the capitalization of “pony” all through the transcript. On this yr’s evaluation, that is not a difficulty.
For comparability, Otter returned a doc with three errors associated to correct nouns and place names however many extra errors in punctuation. TranscribeMe made seven errors in its automated transcript, additionally principally associated to correct nouns and punctuation. Rev made extra errors than Otter associated to correct nouns (six) however was significantly better at capitalization and punctuation.
Whereas we haven’t any considerations about how Scribie performs, some customers are nonetheless more likely to need the choice to skip the automated transcription course of altogether in favor of a human editor. For comparability, GoTranscript and Rev each provide absolutely human-based transcription companies.
Is Your Information Secure With Scribie?
Scribie’s privacy policy outlines its primary safeguards for shielding your recordsdata, together with having workers and contractors signal non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). Moreover, Scribie will signal an NDA upon request.
In line with its web site, the corporate says it would “disclose private info after we imagine it violates our Phrases of Service or is suitable to adjust to the legislation, to guard our or our customers’ rights, in addition to to guard our customers from fraudulent, abusive, and illegal use of our website.” It additionally says the corporate reserves the appropriate to reveal its clients’ “personally identifiable info as required by legislation and after we imagine that disclosure is critical to guard our rights and/or to adjust to a judicial continuing, court docket order, or authorized course of served on our web site.”
We could not discover any approach to allow multi-factor authentication within the account settings part, which is one thing we want to see.
Verdict: Fairly Priced Human-Verified Transcription
Scribie is price testing in the event you want an reasonably priced, pay-as-you-go service that goes past customary machine transcription. It returns correct recordsdata in brief order, and its net interface is usually nice to make use of. Nonetheless, we want Scribie supplied a devoted cell expertise and some extra superior options. As such, it falls in need of our Editors’ Selection winners. GoTranscript offers you the flexibleness to decide on between absolutely automated and human-based transcription companies, whereas Otter has top-notch cell apps and genuinely helpful AI capabilities.
Ben Moore contributed to this evaluation
The Backside Line
Scribie is an economical transcription service that delivers high quality recordsdata rapidly, however it could possibly actually use a cell app to maintain up with the competitors.
Like What You are Studying?
This text might include promoting, offers, or affiliate hyperlinks.
By clicking the button, you verify you’re 16+ and comply with our
Terms of Use and
Privacy Policy.
You could unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.
About Meg St-Esprit
Contributor
